Steven Universe’s alien species of Gems are aliens, which means they aren’t human, and they don’t have sex, they don’t have gender. They are sexless. They are genderless. I saw all these posts about how they are non-binary, but no. Gems have absolutely no concept of gender in their society, therefore the concept of a ‘binary’ wouldn’t even occur to them. Genderless. Gems.
Gems have their own language, and likely that language is completely not gendered. In their original language, they probably wouldn’t have gendered pronouns – no ‘she’ or ‘he’. Just one word that is probably something like ‘they’ to refer to someone that is not themselves. Like many languages in the world right now.
When they came to earth and interacted with humans, they probably thought our sexual reproduction was the weirdest thing ever, as was anything related to that. In English, we still don’t have an official gender-neutral pronoun, so I’m guessing for the sake of the show, the producers didn’t use ‘they’ to refer to the gems – too confusing. In show, for the Gems, they simply adapted the local language to describe themselves, and the pronoun they might have arbitrarily chose was ‘she’. I highly doubt it’s because they ‘identify’ as female or women – they can’t, really, and they haven’t in the show at all, I don’t think, they always acknowledge themselves just as ‘gems’, because they aren’t human – it was for communication’s sake.
That’s in show. In our reality, I’m so happy the producers chose to present them as women in our understanding – as in any regular person looking at the show and not thinking too deeply would just see them as female characters. Which is important because female representation of such variety is so desperately needed. How Garnet, Amethyst, Pearl, Lapis, Jasper, Peridot are so different but still are female characters – a girl and woman can be anything, the message is saying – strong, smart, funny, amazing, warlike, muscular, fat, thin, giant, graceful, crude, arrogant, forgiving, tough, sweet, vengeful, weird, etc.
So I hope they never introduce a ‘male’ gem. Besides, there’s Steven, and Steven is such a great character already.
Headcannon that the gems never identify as women like human women because they didn’t see themselves as women, but also because they knew they would never understand and experience the life of a human female.
We see them as ‘gendered’, and interpret what they do as what a female character is doing – which is necessary for the sake of the cartoon and our media – but the gems have never considered themselves so. Everything they are and do is gem behavior. They technically live in a society where there is no gender. Thumbs up.
This is an excellent analysis. The gems are for the story’s sake women just like how transformers and fictional alien species with no sexes are interpreted to be male (like the Namek from Dragon Ball Z).
Another thing is Steven calls Garnet, Amethyst and Pearl his moms and he calls fusions like Opal and Sardonyx giant women. So you are right that they are seen as women despite not classifying biologically as women or even human (not sure how Rose Quartz and Greg had Steven though).